Hiring has always been a big part of running a business. But today, it feels harder than ever. Many companies are short on staff, yet struggle to find people who truly fit. Job seekers apply to several places at once and often accept offers quickly.
You miss your chance if you wait too long, or your message sounds like every other job post. That’s why hiring can’t be treated like just another task. It needs focus, speed, and a clear plan.
Ryan Naylor understands this better than most. He’s the founder and CEO of AvaHR and Chief Executive Officer at LocalWork, a hiring tool built to help small businesses find great people faster. With more than 17 years of experience, he’s hired hundreds of employees and helped thousands of others do the same.
In 2011, he launched a local job board that connected over 100,000 job seekers to real work. Today, he focuses on helping companies improve how they post jobs, tell their story, and build better teams.
In this article, we’ll learn simple and proven ways to improve A-Player Hiring. You’ll see how to ask the right questions, act quickly, use your team in hiring, and write clear job posts. You’ll also learn how the right tools can save time, reduce stress, and help you hire people who truly care.
Our Sponsors:
Our Affiliates:
How Can You Identify and Improve A-Player Hiring?
Hiring great people isn’t about luck. It’s about asking the right questions and spotting clear signs. One simple way to tell who’s good? Ask for a detailed story.
A-players can explain what they did, how they helped, and why it mattered. They remember real things clearly. B-players give vague answers or skip over the important parts. That’s a strong clue.
A Simple Test to Spot the Best
Try this: ask them to share a time they helped a customer through a tough situation. A-players will explain their steps, what the customer was worried about, and how they solved it. B-players often speak in general terms or don’t remember much. That tells you a lot.
Why B-Players Cost You More in the Long Run
It might seem smart to hire someone who costs a bit less. But B-players often cause more problems than they solve.
They:
- Waste time with mistakes
- Misses chances for referrals because of poor service
- Cause hidden costs like extra fuel or careless damage
- Push better team members away with ego or drama
They might even act like they’re doing great, but their work doesn’t match their words. Over time, that hurts the team and the business.
Reference Checks That Support A-Player Hiring Decisions
Don’t skip reference checks. They’re free and can save you from a bad hire. Just call three people. Ask direct questions, but always ask this:
“If you had the chance, would you hire this person again?”
That one question often tells you everything you need to know. Hiring right takes effort, but it pays off. Good people make your job easier, your team stronger, and your customers happier.
What does an ATS do for A-Player Hiring Success?
An ATS, short for Applicant Tracking System, helps you stay organized while hiring. It works like a customer system, but it tracks job applicants instead of leads. You can keep resumes, notes, and messages all in one spot.
What Makes It Helpful
With an ATS, you don’t need to check emails or dig through files. Everything is right there. You can:
- Store applicant details
- Add comments after each step
- Send emails or texts from one place
- See where each person is in the process
- Post your job on big sites like Indeed and LinkedIn for free
That last part saves money. Job boards often charge for reach, but an ATS gives free posting through approved links. That means small businesses get the same exposure without big costs.
Why It’s Better Than Old-School Hiring
Many still use folders or spreadsheets to track hiring. That takes time and causes mistakes. You may miss someone great just because their resume got lost.
An ATS makes things faster. You can review people, filter out poor fits, and move forward without delays. It also helps catch those who don’t follow instructions or give short, lazy answers.
How to Simplify Steps for A-Player Hiring
Still, don’t add too many steps. That can push good people away. Keep it short and simple:
- Ask a few basic questions
- Add short written answers
- Use one-way video if needed
- Then do your final interview
Each step should show if someone is serious or just sending out resumes at random. That way, you talk only to the ones who fit.
Ultimately, an ATS saves time, cuts stress, and helps you hire the right people without extra work.
Why Speed and Storytelling Strengthen A-Player Hiring?
Hiring the right people isn’t just about posting a job and waiting. Good candidates apply fast and move on even faster. On average, someone looking for work applies to about seven jobs in one go. If they do this a few times a week, they send dozens of applications.
Don’t Wait to Reach Out
In busy markets, timing matters. For example, in Phoenix, there are often over 300 HVAC jobs open at the same time. That means you’re not the only one looking for talent.
If you wait more than a day to call someone, there’s a good chance they’ve already accepted another offer.
Reaching out quickly shows you care. It helps you connect before someone else does. That quick call or message could be the difference between hiring a strong team member and missing out.
Tell a Real Story, Not Just a Job Description
Most job posts sound the same. They list demands and forget the human side. But good candidates want more than a paycheck. They want to feel part of something.
Instead of jumping into duties and rules, start with:
- Who you are: Share how long you’ve been in business or how many customers you’ve helped.
- What you do: Keep it simple. Say what your service is in a few clear words.
- Why it matters: Give people a reason to care. For example, “We help parents get time back with their families.”
This kind of story sticks. A-players want to work where they feel proud. If your job post shows that purpose, you’re more likely to get their attention, and keep it.
How to Spot A-Players and Improve A-Player Hiring Results?
Hiring the right person means looking past resumes. You need to ask the right questions and move fast.
A-players speak with clarity and give real examples. They remember what they did and why it mattered. B-players, on the other hand, often give vague answers or lack detail.
Try asking:
- Tell me about a time you helped a customer through a hard moment?
- What’s your why?
If someone has no clear reason for doing the job, they may not stay long. You want someone who shows purpose, not just someone chasing a paycheck.
Act Quickly
Timing matters, especially during busy seasons. If you wait too long, the right person might go elsewhere. Try calling them within 24 hours of getting the application. That first call can make a big impact.
Involve Your Team to Improve A-Player Hiring
Your team can help spot a good fit. One smart idea is to hold a simple get-together. For example, some companies invite candidates to a casual event like a BBQ or fishing contest.
This gives you the chance to see how they interact with others. You’ll quickly notice who fits in and who doesn’t.
Use Tools That Save Time
You don’t need to start from zero. Use templates for job posts, emails, and interviews. These tools can make the process smoother and faster. Many are free and easy to adjust to your business.
To sum it up: ask clear questions, move fast, involve your team, and use helpful tools. These steps make hiring easier and help you bring in people who care.
Conclusion
Hiring the right people takes more than reading resumes. It takes clear steps and smart choices. A-Player Hiring means knowing what to look for and acting fast when you find it.
Ask real questions, not just about skills but also about their purpose. People who care about their work tend to stay longer and perform better.
Use simple tools like an ATS to stay organized and save time. It helps you track applicants, post jobs, and sort the best ones quickly. Involve your team in the process. They can often spot good fits based on how someone communicates and connects.
Also, don’t wait too long to follow up. Good candidates won’t stay available for long. A quick call or email shows respect and interest. That simple step can help you hire someone who truly adds value.
Make your job posts clear and honest. Share who you are, what you do, and why it matters. People want to work for a company with a purpose, not just a paycheck.
By building a fast, clear, and people-focused process, you attract the right kind of talent. You spend less time fixing hiring mistakes and more time growing your team. The steps are simple but make a big difference when done right.
FAQs
What does A-Player Hiring mean?
A-Player Hiring means finding people who care, work hard, and help the team grow. They bring real value from day one.
How often should I update my job post for A-Player Hiring?
Update your job post at least every few months. This keeps it fresh and helps you stand out to top candidates.
Does company culture matter in A-Player Hiring?
Yes. A-players look for a strong culture. They want to work with teams that care, share goals, and support each other.
Should I hire fast during busy seasons?
Hire fast, but stay smart. Don’t skip steps. Just keep things short and clear so you don’t lose great people.
Can I train someone to become an A-player?
You can train skills, but not drive. If someone cares, learns fast, and shows effort, they may grow into an A-player.
Resources And People Mentioned:
Join the Service Business Mastery Facebook Group for more updates!
This Episode is Kindly Sponsored By:
- Sera (visit their website)
- UpFrog (visit their website)
- CallRail (visit their website)
- CompanyCam (visit their website) Visit CompanyCam and use code SBM for a free 2-week trial, 1:1 training and account setup, and 50% off your first two months!
- MarketStorm (visit their website)
- Lace (visit their website)
- priceguide (visit their website)
Affiliate Links:
- Castmagic (visit their website)
- StreamYard (visit their website)
- IfTTT- 10 Percent off! (visit their website)
- ZyraTalk (Visit their website)
